Skip to content

The Doubter style in Kotia: an argument tested for weak spots

The Doubter is a Kotia style that retells an argument, finds its weak spot, tests it on an extreme case and states conclusions with caution.

Updated

"The Doubter" is a Kotia style that weighs an argument out loud: retells it, looks for the weak spot and tests it on an extreme case. The author gives conclusions carefully, marking them as his suspicion.

The style suits analyses of disputed claims, columns about choices and advice with caveats. You provide the claim and the material, and the agent goes through the argument step by step. The style does not invent facts, figures or sources: it relies only on your material.

How this voice differs

The main techniques: the author first retells someone else's argument fairly and only then strikes at one premise or one step of the inference. A rule is tested on extreme cases, such as unusual objects and extreme scales, to see where it stops working. Disputed conclusions are marked in the first person as a supposition, and a plausible objection is acknowledged and then limited. Working definitions are stated openly and the author keeps coming back to them. The text leaves open the missing evidence and the checks that would move the question forward, while reservations and personal reactions go into parentheses.

"Against Intuition" also tests a tempting idea, but is built around an unusual opening case and a turn at the end. "The Doubter" stays inside the testing itself. "Thinking Aloud" counts together with the reader and closes a section with a joke.

How to apply it to your material

Open "Settings" → "Author style", find "The Doubter" with the search or the "Category" filter (the "Reflective" group), click the card and then the "Select" choice icon in the description on the right. The chosen style applies everywhere: in the chat, in articles and in news. You can also ask Kotia right in the chat: "write … in the The Doubter style".

After turning it on, you can write:

Analyse the claim "the more steps a day, the better you feel" for a habits blog. Material: a reader poll in which only people who already walk a lot took part. Write what is worth checking.

You provide the claim and the data: the style analyses what you passed in and adds no studies or figures.

How to keep the voice for a series of analyses

In the settings of the writing step in the workflow, click "Choose" in the "Style" row and connect "The Doubter". From now on, this voice will be used every time the step runs, and you can change the material in the input.

The built-in style has no separate fields: the topic, the length and the format of the analysis are specified in the task. To capture your own manner more accurately, you can connect your own style instead of the built-in one.

The style is applied together with the task. There is no separate run and no charge for connecting it.